Invite Them Back!

One way that I have sought to enrich the experience of my students is to give them opportunities to learn from others rather than just myself. To them I am the expert but in many facets of what I teach, particularly the practical elements, I am only a few steps further on than they are; and in fact many of them, by the time they reach A2 Level, surpass me in technical skill. It is for this reason that each year I invite one or two ex-students back to school, involving them with my classes throughout the days that they are in.

Why do this? What are the benefits?

1. The students enjoy learning from someone else who is not the ‘teacher’, who to them is only a few years on from where they are now. This relationship sits somewhere between peer and role model and I find that the attentiveness of the students when working with the ex-student is very high.

2. The ex-student is becoming an expert in their chosen field. Take Sophie, who I will be telling you more about a little later in this post. She has just completed her final year of animation at UWE in Bristol. She knows far more than I do about the nuts and bolts of developing an animation from conception to realisation.

3. The process can also be a highly enriching one, where both the current students and ex-students learn from it. Sophie has said to me recently that coming back into school in this role helped her to develop her confidence and add clarity to what she was learning and why.

SophieSophie

Sophie is an ex-Media and Art student who decided to pursue a career in Animation. Upon receiving her results she was accepted on to the animation course at the University of West England in Bristol. Always an enthusiastic student and never one to shy away from work she emailed me early into her first year telling me how much she was enjoying the course. Towards the end of the email she asked if I minded that she visited the school during her spring break and could she be of any help. I wasn’t sure what I would her get her to do exactly but new that there would definitely be a benefit in having another enthusiastic individual around the department. I replied with an enthusiastic yes. Since then Sophie has returned at least once each year for the past three.

While she is here she involves herself in a number of ways supporting students in both the Media and Art department. She has stood in front of my tutor group talking enthusiastically about university life. She has done a similar job in front of my Y13 Media class discussing her work and the rigours/enjoyment of university level study. She also joins the GCSE classes and supports the students by lending a critical eye to their coursework. On her most recent visit she sat down 1-2-1 with a number of my Creative Media Diploma students offering them advice about the development of animations they were creating for an festival they ran in March. My students found her presence in the class to be very valuable and they recorded her feedback as part of their development.

The students’ response to Sophie is always excellent, in part this is down to her personality but also I believe that she inhabits a space between teacher and student – she is both expert but someone who is not too far from their own age. The level of engagement on the part of the students seems to be tweaked up a notch. Similar to what happens on project days where we invite creative practitioners into school. They are not ‘teacher’ and therefore the relationship is different.

During her most recent visit she also helped to develop my students understanding of how an animation project evolves. She was in the pre-production stages of her final project and she used her blog to illustrate the different activities she was working through. This included:

  • making life studies to create realistic characters
  • testing things and creating short practice animations
  • developing ideas through drawing, storyboarding and discussion

She also shared her thoughts and feelings about:

  • inspiration and where it comes from
  • the difficulty of working in groups
  • why she is specialising in ‘pre-production’ and illustration
  • and what she is working on for her final project

The students found her insights fascinating, as did I. The process was all the more enriching due to the fact that she has continued to blog all of her work, a process she adopted as an A-Level Media student.

Not only has Sophie been a valuable resource inside the classroom. This past year she was a guest blogger on the Media Studies department blog, sharing ideas and useful resources. This worked really well, providing a further source of information for my students to draw from.

What’s more it has led me to consider other ‘online’ ways that I could get ex-students involved in supporting my students, such as a Facebook group or connecting them via Twitter, so that they can seek advice and guidance from a wider pool. I’m certainly giving this serious thought in preparation for next year.

I firmly believe that asking ex-students to come back and contribute to the learning of my current students has been invaluable. I would recommend, that if you are not doing this with your students, you should seriously consider it. The problem I face next year is who do I choose to replace Sophie as she steps out into her future career.

If you want to know more about Sophie and her work, use the following links:

Illiteracy: Ignoring the root of the problem

This post is a response to the article: ‘My pledge to end the shocking blight of illiteracy‘, written by Michael Gove, published in the London Evening Standard on Friday 10th June 2011.

For Michael Gove to recognise that there is a problem with literacy in the UK is pleasing yet also inane, in that anyone working in education could have told you the same thing. What is less pleasing but equally meaningless is his proposal to solve this “blight of illiteracy”, by testing students as young as six years old. In his words, this will “give every parent the reassurance of knowing their child will have a reading check – a literacy MoT – at the age of six.” I’m not sure what reassurance this will offer exactly? It is more likely to cause greater stress for both the parent and (more importantly) the child. What’s more it will create more form filling and data analysis for teachers, surely not the best use of their time. Without a well thought out program to tackle why young children are not reading and writing well, another test is simply pointless.

Equally worrying was the suggestion that extra funding would be provided to support the poorest students, should they be found to be under performing. While I’m not about to dispute the notion that children from poorer backgrounds are likely to struggle with reading and writing, I am not of the belief that they are the only young people who at school struggle with literacy. Many students who come from more affluent backgrounds have difficulties with reading and writing. The fact is that there are a significant number of factors that can impact on a young persons development as a reader and writer. Money is not the sole cause of illiteracy and it is not the sole answer to solving it either.

Gove and the government are (in my opinion) ignoring key issues and not getting to the root of the problem. The fact is that improving teacher training (also proposed in the article) is not a bad idea; there is always room for improvement. However, if this plan is based on a belief that teachers are not doing their jobs properly, that the current crop of teachers do not have the skills to help improve the literacy of children across the UK, then I believe this is highly misguided. I know and work alongside many excellent teachers across a wide range of departments, who are more than equipped to tackle this “blight of illiteracy”, but who have little time to address it effectively in what is an over-crowded curriculum. It is also the case that many talented teachers have fallen into the trap of teaching to the test. Exam boards have given less prevalence to the basics in order to boost results. The quality of a students spelling, punctuation and grammar counts for very little in the current AQA GCSE English curriculum and even less in English Literature. Arguably, at the present time, education is not focussed on tackling the fundamentals or addressing individual student needs – how could it be when schools are forced to be so target driven?

I’m not naive enough to believe that all teachers are perfect and must acknowledge that some teachers are not well equipped to tackle illiteracy when they can’t spell or demarcate a sentence correctly themselves? However, I do wonder why this is. Are we now seeing (in UK graduates) the by-product of ‘teach the test’ culture, created by target driven education? Are graduates accepted on to teacher training courses and awarded NQT status because so many teachers leave the profession after a few short years? Should the Government not be considering how to attract top graduates into teaching? Surely, if teachers were paid better standards would go up. It irks me to have said that. I, for one, am not in this for the money, but I don’t believe it’s that misguided to believe that a student graduating with a first in Biology is more likely to consider Medical School than a PGCE to teach Secondary school kids Science. The future career prospects (particularly financially) are far more appealing.

More tests; more money; improved teacher training – none of these ideas actually begin to address the root of the problem. The fact is that the road to becoming literate begins at home. Parents have to take a lead in reading to their children, encouraging and helping them learn to read and write. The proposal in the article that bothered me more than any other was the idea that the Government (meaning the tax payer) would provide “additional funding to make sure every disadvantaged two-year-old child has 15 hours of pre-school learning every week.” Once again money is seen as the answer and more significantly there is a continuation of what I feel has been an over-arching approach to education for the last 10-15 years. That approach (an ethos if you will) is that education is the sole responsibility of the state and therefore parents are absolved of their responsibility to educate their children.

Here are some proposals of my own that I believe would actually begin to tackle the real issues. Firstly, lets stop closing public libraries. In fact, lets make sure that every community (village, town, city) has a modern, well-resourced, space where people of all walks of life can come to read, research, and learn. The disparity between people’s experiences of what a library can be is huge. Just compare my local library in Gerrards Cross with the facilities available at the library in High Wycombe. High Wycombe library, like many city libraries, offers a hugely attractive space and wealth of resources to their communities. I believe that all communities should have such a resource at their finger tips.

Chalfont St Peter library, just a couple of miles down the road from me, is under threat of closure. The minute it closes, access to affordable resources for reading/learning have been cut off from the poorest people in the community. If these smaller, local libraries were better funded and resourced, the government would not need to throw money at poor families as suggested by Gove in the article. Would it not be economically (and environmentally) more sound to improve on the facilities that already exist? Perhaps the counter argument to the proposal above is that it leaves responsibility with the local community to go and use it. I firmly believe that if you make libraries relevant to the 21st Century, that if you fund them well and make them attractive spaces people will use them. It is lack of funding and level of neglect that ultimately decides the fate of many local libraries.

Therefore, I offer a second proposal. Instead of absolving parents of their responsibility in helping their children to learn to read and write. Why not provide them with the means to do so? For those poorer families in the community, why not give a portion of their welfare to them in the form of vouchers that can only be used in local libraries to borrow books or to buy books from retailers? This would raise the profile of reading across the nation and say to parents you have a responsibility to your children to not only ensure that they are fed, clothed and well looked after; you also have a responsibility to kick-start their education. Don’t get me wrong, I know that many parents who are raising their children in difficult circumstances, realise this is part of their role. However, for those parents in difficult financial circumstances, lets help them to be able to do it.

A question needs to be asked of publishers and retailers also. Why can Romeo and Juliet be bought for a pound but The Hungry Caterpillar will set you back four or five? Surely, children’s books need to be priced so that they can be afforded by poorer families as well as those with excess income. How this could be achieved, I’m not sure but it seems that books like many other commodities are increasingly over priced and as such become accessible to those who can afford them and inaccessible to those who can’t. This is where libraries have bridged the gap but as I have said before, if libraries close, then a valuable resource is lost. Perhaps then, the Government need to provide incentives to publishers and retailers to lower the cost of books, particularly children’s books to encourage reading.

I know that some of you will be thinking that iPads and Kindle’s provide a potential solution to getting young people reading. But I am unconvinced at this stage, mainly because I refuse to buy-in to the over hyped ‘Digital Natives‘ idea coined by Marc Prensky. Prensky and the many people who buy into his ideas ignore the fact that there is a significant digital divide in UK. The divide is there because of money. In my own classes, only a very small percentage of students have iPads, Smart Phones or Kindles. The majority of them (and I work in quite an affluent area) simply do not have them. If they read, they read from regular old paper books. Until, eBook Readers and Smart Phones are so cheep that they are ubiquitous then it remains that we need to find ways to make good, old, paper books affordable for everyone.

What I am driving at is this: Illiteracy is a societal problem not an solely an education one. Gove is ignoring the root of the problem and can only see a state mandated school-based solution. We need to think more broadly and we need to move the responsibility of ‘literacy’ beyond the four walls of the classroom.

#purposedfutured

purposed-badge

The latest Purpos/ed campaign is called #purposedfutured. In getting involved we were asked to use AudioBoo to interview a person about the future of education, using the following two questions:

A) How should we educate people in the future?

B) What do we need to be doing now to enable that?

Here is my interview with James, an A-Level Media Studies student, nearing the end of his school-based education:

Do you agree/disagree with James’ thoughts? Why not comment below and join the debate? Or add your own voice to the campaign any time by recording your own thoughts and sticking them online. You don’t need to wait for permission but do let the guys at Purpos/ed know so that they can promote and credit you for your contribution.

#mainedu: One module down, two to go…

Having begun the MA in Education, promising to blog my learning journey, I have found that time has been at a premium and thus blog posts have been in short supply. With that in mind, I have squared away a moment or two to provide an update.

As tweeted out earlier last week, I have completed Module 2: Assessment for Learning, achieving a distinction. I subsequently tidied up the corresponding page on this blog to include a summary of the unit; the texts that influenced my understanding and impacted on my assignments; and also added links to both my 1000 word critique of Black and Wiliam’s: ‘Inside the Black Box’ and Action Research Assignment.

While I may be finished with the module, AfL remains an area of significant interest to me. Particularly, because of the way that I have been using Google Docs with my students. Moreover, this is the focus of my School Based Enquiry, for which I continue to collect data.

Based on the feedback I received from my Module 2 tutor, I am planning a trip to Oxford Brookes University Library over the half term break to expand my reading; there are some texts that look useful but I am struggling to find in PDF format online.

Module 3: Developing eLearning began earlier this month. This module will likely prove to be the most enjoyable of the three. As an area of education that I am significantly immersed in, I hope that it will afford me the opportunity to broaden my understanding and refine some of my current practices.

In order to ensure that I don’t simply fall back on tried and tested tools however, I completed an audit of the technologies that are embedded in my current teaching practice and those that are not. It is my intention to develop a series of lessons wherein one of these technologies will be used to facilitate the learning in some way.

Reading for the module has also commenced and for me a number of the texts are old news but nevertheless I will revisit them, making the necessary notes in Evernote to use later in my assignment. We have been given the already well critiqued Prensky articles: ‘Digital Natives, Digital Immigrants’ and ‘Do They Really Think Differently?’ (Digital Natives: Part 2) to read. For some up to date debate on the concept of digital natives, these posts from Simon Bostock and Doug Belshaw are definitely worth checking out:

Finally, I hope that as the unit eveolves I will get the chance to tie in some of the material I have been reading and writing about recently with regards to learning technologies, taxonomies and literacies. Only time will tell.

Audit

A brief audit of edtech tools (I may have missed a few!) in no particular order/preference.

Used and embeded in my teaching practice:

  • Lino (Wallwisher)
  • Google docs
  • YouTube
  • Google Search tools: Wonder Wheel, Advanced Search, Timeline, Images, Books, Scholar
  • Blogging (Blogger, Posterous, WordPress)
  • Office: Word, PowerPoint, Excel
  • Prezi
  • Slideshare
  • Bubbl.us
  • Wordle
  • Moodle (Forum, Wiki, Quiz, Online text, Glossary, Game modules)
  • Adobe Connect (Skype)
  • Adobe Photoshop, Premiere Pro, After Effects (iMovie)
  • Garageband (Audacity)
  • Wikipedia
  • Flip camcorders
  • HD camcorders
  • Digital cameras (inc. Digital SLRs)
  • Apple Mac computers (MacBooks)
  • Mobile Phones
  • IWB

Used but not embeded:

  • Twitter
  • Voicethread
  • Google Maps
  • Google Calendar
  • Cover It Live